Which alternative for which night
Four people, four pads, one room, and you want noise. Overcooked! All You Can Eat. One to four players locally and online, full crossplay, and it is both Overcooked games remastered in one purchase. It will test friendships, which is the point. It is also the pick that most reliably works when half the group is somewhere else, because the crossplay has no conditions attached.
Six to eight people and the smallest budget. Human: Fall Flat. One to eight, crossplay across platforms, and the cheapest game on this page. The humour comes entirely from the wobbly physics going wrong, so skill is irrelevant - which is the single most Jackbox-like quality any of these have.
A big group, including people who are not in the room. Among Us. Four to fifteen players, full crossplay, online and local, and perfect over a voice call - which is the other thing Jackbox is normally used for. Our Among Us review covers what it costs on which platform, since it is free on mobile and paid elsewhere.
Five or six people who want something short and loud. TMNT: Shredder's Revenge. Up to six players at once, locally or online, and nobody needs to be good at it. A full run is short. No crossplay is listed, so everyone playing online needs the same platform.
A mixed-age room that wants turns. MONOPOLY 2024. Up to six locally - and usefully, the PlayStation listing notes it works with one controller or one each, so it is the one pick here that does not force you to buy pads.
What a Jackbox night actually is, and how to rebuild it
Worth naming, because it tells you what to look for. A Jackbox evening is short rounds (nothing lasts long enough to get boring), no elimination (everyone plays every round), no skill requirement (being funny beats being good), and zero setup. Score the alternatives against those four and the ranking on this page falls out: Human: Fall Flat and Among Us keep three of the four, Overcooked keeps short rounds and no elimination, TMNT keeps no-elimination and no-skill, Fall Guys keeps only the short rounds - which is why it is the skip.
None of them keep zero setup. That belongs to the phone, and the phone belongs to Jackbox.
If the group is on a video call
This is the case Jackbox is quietly best at, and it is where most alternatives fall over, because a screen share cannot give a remote player controller input. The ones that genuinely work at distance are Among Us (built for it), Overcooked (crossplay online), MONOPOLY 2024 (online) and TMNT (online, same platform). Our games over a video call page is the full version of that list, and games with coworkers covers the work-social version where nobody wants to install anything.
If you are going to buy another pack after all
That is often the right call, and there is one buying note worth having: Amazon stocks the Jackbox back catalogue rather than the newest pack, so if you specifically want the current one, buy it direct from a console or PC store. Our Jackbox Party Pack review covers what is in Pack 6 and how the phone setup works, and phone games for a room is the page for a group whose only hardware is the phones they walked in with.
Coming at it from the other direction - a Switch household that wants a party board game instead - is Mario Party alternatives.