Which alternative for which room
A room where only one person owns anything. The Jackbox Party Pack 6. Only the host buys it; everyone else goes to jackbox.tv on a phone and enters a room code, which makes it the lowest-friction group game there is. Pack 6 holds five games including Trivia Murder Party 2 and Push the Button, it seats up to ten players, and it works over a screen share - so the same purchase covers a video call. One buying note: Amazon stocks the back catalogue rather than the newest pack, so if you specifically want the current pack, buy it direct from a console or PC store. Our Jackbox review covers that, and Jackbox alternatives runs this exercise in the other direction.
A mixed-age room that wants turns and a board. MONOPOLY 2024. Up to six locally, one controller or one each, plus online. The PlayStation Store listing is explicit about the local count. It is on PS5, Xbox, Switch and PC, which is the whole point.
Four on a couch who want the minigame feeling without the board. Rayman Legends. One to four local co-op, drop-in, instant respawns, and genuinely one of the best four-player couch platformers ever made. It is couch-only - no online - which is the same constraint Mario Party has, so for a room it changes nothing. Our review covers what Nintendo's listing says about its modes.
Four on a couch who want a kart race. Crash Team Racing Nitro-Fueled. One to four on one system, two to eight online, on PS5, Xbox and Switch. It is the Mario Kart substitute as much as the Mario Party one, and it is noticeably harder than Nintendo's racers - which some groups want and some do not. Our split-screen racing page ranks it against the rest.
Five or six people in one room. TMNT: Shredder's Revenge. It is one of the very few games that seats six at once, locally or online, and nobody needs to be good at it. A full run is short, and no crossplay is listed, so everyone playing online needs the same platform.
Two people and the smallest possible budget. Hot Wheels Unleashed 2 - Turbocharged. One to two on one system, up to twelve online, and the cheapest thing here. No crossplay is listed by the publisher.
If the group is bigger than four
This is where Mario Party struggles too - most boards are built for four, with a few modes stretching further. Jackbox at ten players and TMNT at six are the two picks that genuinely scale, and both do it without needing more controllers. Our games for large groups page covers five players and up properly, and five players handles the specific awkward number.
If the group is not in the room
Half of this list is couch-only, which is fine for a party and useless for a video call. The picks that work at distance are Jackbox (screen share), MONOPOLY 2024 (online), TMNT (online, same platform) and Crash Team Racing (online, same platform). Rayman Legends and Hot Wheels' local mode do not travel. Our long-distance hub and games with coworkers cover that case from the other end.
If you do have a Switch
Then the honest answer may be to buy Mario Party after all, and the useful question is which one. We compare the two current entries directly in which Mario Party? and weigh the series against Nintendo's other party staple in Mario Kart vs Mario Party. There is also a full Jamboree review if you want the detail before committing fifty dollars.
And if the real constraint is the fifty dollars rather than the console, the cheap Switch shelf is its own page: best Switch games under $25. The same Switch-only problem applies to Nintendo's other household staple, and Mario Kart alternatives runs this exact exercise for the kart racer.