Which pick for which room
Four people, one PS5 or Xbox, tonight. Sonic Racing: CrossWorlds, then Crash Team Racing Nitro-Fueled. CrossWorlds is the current game - four-player local split-screen with the race rules exposed, so you can set item sets and AI difficulty to suit the room - and it is the only genuinely new four-player split-screen racer that runs on a non-Nintendo console. Crash Team Racing is the cheaper, older, harder option: Nintendo's listing gives it as single system 1-4 and online 2-8, so four people share one console and one copy.
Four people who are not in the same room. Sonic Racing: CrossWorlds if they are on different platforms, Crash Team Racing if everyone is on the same one. CrossWorlds is the only pick here that combines a four-player couch mode with a cross-platform flag. Crash Team Racing's online is explicitly same-platform, so a mixed group gets nothing from it.
Two people, and the budget is the constraint. Hot Wheels Unleashed 2 - Turbocharged. Milestone's arcade racer on orange plastic track is usually the cheapest racer in this whole category, and its Steam listing carries both "Shared/Split Screen" and "Shared/Split Screen PvP", which almost nothing else on PC does. Nintendo gives the local cap as 1-2 with online 1-12, so read it as a two-player couch game with a big online mode bolted on, not as a four-player replacement.
Nobody wants to pay anything. Rocket League. It is car soccer rather than a kart racer, so it fails the purist test - but it keeps all three properties that matter: a five-minute match, a rule anyone understands in one sentence, and full crossplay across PS5, Xbox, Switch and PC. It is free, which means you can test whether your group wants a car game at all before spending thirty dollars finding out. Our free games to play with friends page covers the rest of that shelf.
You do own a Switch and just want it cheaper. Then the honest answer is that it will not be, and you should buy the real thing. Mario Kart 8 Deluxe is still 1-4 local and up to 12 online, and it holds its price year after year. If you have a Switch 2, Mario Kart World pushes the local cap to four on one system with up to 24 online, which is the highest online figure on this page. We put the two side by side in Mario Kart World vs Mario Kart 8 Deluxe.
What the split-screen caps really are
This is the figure most store pages bury, so here it is in one paragraph. Four on one console: Sonic Racing: CrossWorlds, Crash Team Racing Nitro-Fueled, Mario Kart 8 Deluxe and Mario Kart World. Two on one console: Hot Wheels Unleashed 2 and Gran Turismo 7. Local but not really split-screen: Rocket League, which supports local play on console but is built around online matches. If the four of you are in one room, two of the picks here will leave two people watching - and that is the single most common buying mistake in this category.
A second trap worth naming: the PlayStation and Xbox releases of Crash Team Racing Nitro-Fueled are last-generation discs that run on a PS5 or a Series X through backward compatibility rather than native current-gen versions. It works, it is cheap, and it is not a remaster of the remaster. If that matters to you, Sonic Racing: CrossWorlds is the native pick.
Where the money actually goes
On the day this page was written, every non-Nintendo pick here came in under the price of a single Mario Kart, and three of them came in under half of it. That gap is the whole practical case for this list: a household that would have spent one Nintendo game on one Nintendo racer can instead buy a four-player racer and a second group game, or buy the racer and keep the change. Prices move, so the buttons above are the authority and the figures in this paragraph are deliberately not written as numbers - the live layer is stamped November 21, 2026 and refreshes daily.
If the budget is the real constraint rather than the console, we run the same exercise platform by platform: best PS5 games under $25, Xbox under $50, and Switch under $50 for the band where the Nintendo shelf finally becomes reachable.
What this page is not claiming
We have not raced these head to head on a stopwatch and we do not publish scores, playtime figures or star ratings anywhere on this site. Every player count and crossplay line above comes from a first-party listing - Nintendo's store pages, PlayStation's game pages and Steam's feature lists - and every price comes from a live layer rather than from memory. We also make no claim about which of these is the better driving game; the test applied throughout is whether four people who did not plan their evening can be racing within a minute of switching the console on.
One more thing we are not claiming: that any of these is Mario Kart. They are not. Nintendo's item balance is genuinely unmatched, and if you own the console, buy the real thing. This list is for the households that cannot.
Where to go next
If what you actually want is the party rather than the racing, Mario Party alternatives solves the same Switch-only problem on the board-game side, and games for 4 players ranks the whole four-person shelf. For racers specifically, split-screen racing games goes deeper on the local caps, and our Sonic Racing: CrossWorlds review covers the top pick in detail before you commit.