Which pick for which group
Four friends on three different platforms. Helldivers 2, then Diablo IV. Helldivers is the loud, short-session one where friendly fire is always on by design; Diablo IV is the long-haul grind with cross-progression, which matters if anyone in the group plays on two devices. Neither excludes a PC or Xbox friend. There is still no Switch version of Helldivers 2, so a Switch friend is left out.
Exactly two of you, and only one wants to pay. Split Fiction if you are on different platforms, It Takes Two if you are on the same one. Both are two-player-only asymmetric campaigns from the same studio, both include a Friend's Pass, and Split Fiction adds the crossplay It Takes Two never had. Our head-to-head settles which, and games like It Takes Two is the wider shelf.
A crew that wants one world rather than one level. Sea of Thieves. Crews of up to four per ship in a shared world that PlayStation's page lists at up to twenty-four players, with full crossplay across Xbox, PC and PS5 - and real PvP, which is the honest catch. A crew that hates being boarded will hate it. Our open-world co-op page covers the alternatives.
Exactly three of you. Elden Ring Nightreign, which is the rare game built for precisely three rather than two or four. Run-based, hard, and no crossplay, so match your platforms.
Two on one couch with one television. Halo: Campaign Evolved for the newest big-budget split-screen campaign, Gran Turismo 7 if the racing should be real driving, or Borderlands 3 for the longest shared campaign per dollar. Our split-screen on PS5 page ranks the whole split-screen shelf.
What still sits above $50
Call of Duty: Black Ops 7, EA Sports FC 27, Directive 8020 and LEGO Batman: Legacy of the Dark Knight are all above this line, and a current first-party PlayStation release generally will be too. If any of those is the game you want, the only honest advice is to wait for a sale - our Black Friday page tracks which of them actually move.
How we set the $50 line
The band is read from the price layer, not authored. Every price on this site comes from one source keyed to the retailer's listing and refreshed daily, and thirty-four PS5 titles in our catalog were under fifty dollars when this page was written. We used the upper half deliberately: the lower half already has its own page, and repeating it here would make two pages that say the same thing. No price on this page was typed in, and if the refresh stops every number disappears on its own and the buttons fall back to "Check price on Amazon" - which is why the table carries the date November 21, 2026.
If a number here disagrees with the button, the button is the authority.
Same budget, different machine
For the whole PS5 shelf with no price filter, see best games to play with friends on PS5. For the same exercise on other platforms at the entry band: Xbox under $25, PC under $25 and Switch under $25. At this band on the other machines, Xbox under $50 is the closest sibling to this page and Switch under $50 is the furthest from it - no crossplay flagships, but six-player couch games instead, and PC under $50 is the closest to this page, with the deepest cheap shelf of the four and the same crossplay-led argument. And if the budget is the only thing that matters, cheap games to play with friends drops the platform filter entirely, while multiplayer games under $20 is the hard floor below it.