Which world for which crew
A crew on three different machines. Sea of Thieves. It has been the Game Pass crossplay game since launch, it is Xbox Play Anywhere, and it reached PS5 in April 2024 with cross-platform play - so a mixed crew genuinely sails together. The honest con: it is a slow social sandbox with real PvP. A crew that wants a structured campaign will find it aimless, and a crew that hates being boarded will hate it.
Four people who want loot and a story. Borderlands 4. The series FAQ is specific that console versions run two-player split-screen while online parties reach four, and it is the cheapest thing on this page - which makes it the sensible first purchase for a group that has not played together before. Our Borderlands 4 review covers the split-screen question per platform.
A group that will commit for months. Monster Hunter Wilds. Crossplay across PS5, Xbox and PC, four hunters per quest, and Link Parties that keep the same four people together between them. It is systems-heavy with a real learning curve, so it rewards a group that plays the same game repeatedly and punishes one that does not. Our co-op RPGs page ranks it against the other long-haul picks.
Four who want to build and automate. Palworld - survival crafting where the creatures you catch run the base, mining and farming and fighting while you build. It is the one genuinely new idea in this category. Note the crossplay gap: Steam lists it, PlayStation does not.
A group that wants a deadline. 7 Days to Die. You spend six days mining and fortifying and on the seventh the horde arrives, which is the pressure Minecraft never applies. Its Steam listing is the only one here carrying LAN Co-op as well as online and crossplay, so a group in one house can play off one router. Skip it if anyone dislikes horror - the nights are unpleasant by design.
Exactly three. Elden Ring Nightreign. Three is the hardest number in co-op because almost every design targets two or four, and this one is built for it. Run-based and genuinely hard, with no crossplay.
What this page deliberately leaves out
Minecraft and Terraria. Both are open worlds and both are excellent, but they are building games first and the group question they raise is a different one - caps, crossplay editions and server setup. That is a page of its own: games like Minecraft for a group covers Minecraft, Terraria, Core Keeper and the survival-craft shelf, with the caps spelled out.
MMORPGs. Final Fantasy XIV, New World: Aeternum and Throne and Liberty are open worlds with tens of thousands of people in them, and the thing that decides whether your group can actually meet is server and region policy, not the game. Our MMORPGs with PC and PS5 crossplay page handles that, including which famous names to rule out before anyone buys.
Any live-service game we cannot verify a cap for. If the publisher does not print the number, we do not either.
The practical checks before a long purchase
Who is paying for what. Console online play generally needs a subscription, and on an open-world game you will be in it for months - that cost can exceed the game. Sea of Thieves needs PS Plus on PlayStation and a Microsoft account everywhere. Our free vs paid multiplayer breakdown covers which modes require it.
Whether anyone can host. Palworld and 7 Days to Die both support dedicated servers, which is how a group of more than four plays together - and how you keep a world running when the host is asleep. It is also the one setup step in this category that genuinely takes an evening.
Whether the group actually wants an open world. This is worth asking honestly. Open worlds reward self-directed play; a group that turns up on Friday wanting to be told what to do will have a better time with a structured co-op campaign. Our co-op campaign page is that list, and co-op shooters is the shorter-session version.