Which pick for which group
Two of you, one PS5, one television. Borderlands 4 is the pick: the series FAQ is specific that console versions run two-player split-screen while online parties go to four. LEGO Star Wars: The Skywalker Saga is the gentler alternative - two-player couch co-op across nine films, forgiving of a player who rarely plays, and covered in full in our LEGO Star Wars review.
Four of you, four PS5s. Deep Rock Galactic for about the price of a sandwich, then Overcooked! All You Can Eat. Deep Rock is four-player procedural cave mining with destructible tunnels and genuine teamwork, and it is endlessly replayable; Overcooked is the louder, shorter-session option and the one that crossplays to friends on other systems.
A room of people and one controller. The Quarry. 2K's own FAQ is explicit that up to eight people can each take a character and pass one pad as the story branches - which makes it, per head, the cheapest thing on this page by a wide margin. Our full review covers the Wolf Pack online mode and its limits, and 2-player horror games covers the same shelf for exactly two people.
A group that just wants a sandbox to mess about in. GTA Online is still the open-world playground for up to thirty players and it is cheap and enormous. No crossplay, so everyone has to be on the same platform family. Terraria is the build-together alternative: eight-player co-op, crossplay across most systems on the same version, and effectively endless.
Two of you who want a fight rather than a team. Mortal Kombat 1 is the 1v1 pick. Treat its crossplay as unreliable - it is limited and mode-dependent.
What $25 does not buy on PS5
Three things, and it is worth knowing before you go looking. The marquee crossplay co-op games - Helldivers 2 and Split Fiction - sit above the line, as does It Takes Two, which is the game we recommend more than any other on this site for a pair. Gran Turismo 7 and Sea of Thieves are also out of reach here. All of them are in the next band up, and best PS5 games under $50 is that page.
You also will not find a current first-party PlayStation release. Sony's own games discount slowly, which is why every pick here is third-party.
How we set the $25 line
It is read, not chosen. Every price on this site comes from a single live layer, keyed to the retailer's listing and refreshed daily, and this page exists because that layer reported thirteen PS5 titles in our catalog under twenty-five dollars - comfortably more than enough to make the lowest round band honest. Nothing on this page carries a price we typed in. If the refresh stops, the numbers vanish on their own and every button falls back to "Check price on Amazon", which is why the table is stamped November 21, 2026 rather than described as current.
Prices in this band move fast, and they move most around the end of November - our Black Friday page tracks which of these actually drop further. If a number on this page disagrees with the button, the button is right.
Same budget, different console
The shelf is not the same on every machine, mostly because of what each platform's first-party publisher does with its prices. We run the same exercise for Xbox under $25, Switch under $25 and PC under $25 - the PC list is the longest and the Switch list the most couch-weighted. If the budget matters more than the platform, cheap games to play with friends drops the platform filter entirely.