Which pick for which pair
Two of you, different platforms, tonight. Escape Academy, then We Were Here Forever. These are the only two picks here with a Cross-Platform Multiplayer flag, which is the property that decides everything else. Escape Academy is the friendlier of the two - it has a shared-screen mode as well as online, so it also works if you end up in the same room - while We Were Here Forever is online-only with no single-player mode at all, and nobody can play it muted. Both are escape-room games rather than action-adventures, so the pace is slower than Split Fiction's.
Two of you, same platform, and only one wants to pay. It Takes Two, then A Way Out. Both carry the Friend's Pass model, both are two-player-only designed campaigns, and both are from the studio that made Split Fiction - so the design language is identical. It Takes Two lists online co-op plus a split-screen mode on every platform it is on; A Way Out is told entirely in split-screen even when you play it online, which no other game here does. Neither has crossplay.
Two of you, one couch, and one of you is a kid. LEGO Horizon Adventures. PlayStation lists it at 1-2 players with up to two online, Steam carries both Online Co-op and Shared/Split Screen Co-op, and it is the cheapest of the newer picks on this page. It is also the gentlest - a pair who wanted Split Fiction's difficulty spikes will find it forgiving, which is exactly why it works with a child holding the second controller. Our games to play with family page is the wider version of that shelf.
Two of you who want the story, not the set-pieces. Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons Remake. One brother each, one controller each, and the same we-are-in-this-together structure Hazelight builds everything around. Steam lists Co-op and Shared/Split Screen Co-op with no Online Co-op entry, and PlayStation gives 1-2 players with no online line, so treat it as a same-room game or a Remote Play Together game. It is also the one pick here you can finish alone - one thumbstick per brother - which answers the people searching for a single-player version of this feeling.
Two of you who want puzzles, properly. Portal 2, and then Escape Academy 2 if you have run out. Portal 2's co-op campaign is a separate designed mode for two players who each hold half of every solution, and it is still the best cooperative problem-solving anyone has shipped. Escape Academy 2: Back 2 School arrived on 5 November 2026, which makes it the newest two-player co-op game on this site - Online Co-op and Shared/Split Screen Co-op on its Steam listing, no cross-platform flag, and a PlayStation page that returned a 404 on the day we checked, so we list it as a PC pick only. The deeper version of that shelf is co-op games like Portal 2.
There are three of you, not two. Then the whole premise breaks, and Trine 5 is the pick: Steam carries Online Co-op, LAN Co-op, Shared/Split Screen Co-op and Remote Play Together, and each hero has one tool, so puzzles are solved by combining people. It is the only game on this page that scales past two. Games for 3 players covers the rest of that problem.
What about Split Fiction itself?
If you have not played it, buy it rather than an alternative. It is the only game in this category that is designed for two, crossplay-flagged and Friend's Pass enabled at the same time, which is why this page exists in the first place - everything else drops at least one of those. It sat at the top of the under-$50 band in our live price layer on November 21, 2026, so it is also no longer a full-price purchase. Our Split Fiction notes and It Takes Two vs Split Fiction cover which of the two to start with.
What this page is not claiming
We have not played these head to head on a stopwatch, and we publish no scores, no playtime figures and no star ratings anywhere on this site. Every mode flag above comes from Steam's own feature list and every player count from PlayStation's US game page, both read on the date in the comment at the top of this file. Nintendo's US store returned a server error to every request on that date, so no Nintendo figure is quoted here - which is also why the Switch versions of some picks are not listed. Prices come from a live layer stamped November 21, 2026, never from memory, and no figure in this prose is a price.
One more thing we are not claiming: that any of these is Split Fiction. None is. If the specific thing you loved was the genre-switching - a cyberpunk chase, then dragons, then a cooking show - no other game on the market does that, and the honest answer is to replay it with a different friend using the Friend's Pass.
Where to go next
If your pair is mixed-platform, the crossplay hub filters the whole catalog to games that bridge consoles, and best two-player co-op games is the full version of this shelf without the Split Fiction filter. On budget, the band these picks mostly sit in is multiplayer games under $20, and best PC games under $50 is where Split Fiction itself now lands.